Travel ban has trainers fuming
PUBLISHED: December 29, 2014
David Thiselton
Star filly Majmu is currently a 4-1 ante-post shot for next month’s J&B Met but there is a chance that she might not make it due to a travel ban placed on Randjesfontein horses following a recent positive case of African Horse Sickness (AHS) in the vicinity. Accordingly she should either be at longer odds or betting on her should be suspended.
Sean Tarry has already been affected by the ban as he was unable to obtain a travel permit for Trip To Heaven, who was due to run in the Gr 2 Khaya Stables Diadem Stakes at Kenilworth on the weekend. He would also like to take Carry On Alice down for one of two potential Cape Summer Of Champions Season targets in January.
The ban, which affects horses within a 30km radius of the AHS outbreak, was made by the state veterinary authority in order to protect the AHS Controlled Area in the Western Cape in line with the export protocol negotiated with the European Union (EU) in 1997.
However, every time there is an outbreak in the AHS Controlled Area the EU imposes a 24 month ban on equine exports from South Africa. The net result is that South Africa has been suspended from exporting more often than it has been free to do so.
This is totally unreasonable considering AHS is a seasonal disease due to the fact that the culicoides midge that carries the virus cannot survive the cold of winter.
As a result of outbreaks in the Western Cape earlier this year, the current ban on direct travel to the EU will only end in July 2016, provided there is no further outbreak in the AHS Controlled Area before then.
Mike de Kock fumed on Tellytrack’s Winning Ways last week and said that South Africa should “stop pandering” to the EU and instead find alternate travel routes. Travelling via China could become an option and De Kock also believes direct travel to the UAE could soon be a reality.
De Kock added, “What message are we sending to the rest of the world (who are placing travel restrictions on us) if we are placing travel restrictions on ourselves.”
What further incensed De Kock was that a precedent had already been set in 2012 when Igugu was able to obtain a special permit to travel to the J&B Met which she won.
Tarry attempted to obtain a special permit this month to transport Trip To Heaven but it was refused and an appeal against this decision was also rejected.
He was told that the special permits obtained in 2011/2012, which enabled Igugu as well as his own horses Pomodoro and The Hangman to travel to Cape Town, were given by a provincial state veterinarian who did not have the authority to do so.
However, this particular veterinarian clearly had the interests of racing at heart and Tarry said, “We are saying ‘So what!’ Look at the facts, the special permits were given, the conditions were complied with and there was no negative effect. The PCR test (that was developed at the Equine Research Centre, Faculty of Veterinary Science at Onderstepoort) was a massive breakthrough, we used it and the horses tested negative on this side and negative down in Cape Town.
“We are at a loss to understand why we are being treated like this when a precedent was set in the best interests of racing. Science was applied and we covered all bases. The proof of the pudding is in the eating.”
Tarry added that he and De Kock had been weighing up several options, including travel by air, but the veterinary authority had not been prepared to discuss them.
The ban effects the entire horse population and the state does not recognise that racehorses are kept under special conditions that significantly lessen the likelihood of infection compared with the general horse population.
Tarry said, “racehorses are kept in a sterile environment and AHS vaccinations are administered by veterinarians and policed by the NHRA. The 30km radius enforcement has no scientific backing. Each case should be seen on its individual merits rather than making a broad ban. Furthermore, the restrictions are made on guidelines only and there are no set rules in place, so discretion should be able to be used.”
Tarry and De Kock have not given up on their quest to obtain the travel permits.
Captain back on song
PUBLISHED: December 29, 2014
Michael Clower
Captain Of All now goes for the Betting World Cape Flying Championship after blowing a gaping hole in the second-run-after-a-rest theory in the Khaya Stables Diadem Stakes at Kenilworth on Saturday.
Sean Cormack had sufficient confidence in the Duncan Barry-bred Captain Al colt to send him on almost 400m out and the Joostes’ 15-2 chance held the slightly unlucky Copper Parade by almost half a length, albeit a dwindling one.
Third-placed Fly By Night had problems getting a clear run and Richard Fourie had to snatch up to avoid a crashing fall on Ashton Park (equal 5th) but Dennis Drier was delighted to see last year’s Gold Medallion winner back on song.
He said: “Captain Of All never had any major issues but he had a little stifle injury and then a small joint problem. It was annoying but what he needed was rest and time, and I took him to my farm just outside Summerveld.”
Asstar will also be in the Cape Flying line-up after making a bold bid to run his rivals ragged in the Capetown Noir Need For Speed Sprint. Despite racing into the teeth of a strong headwind, it was only in the last two strides that this brave little horse was collared by Grant Behr on 50-1 shot Varlo.
Glen Puller said: “He only turned three 27 days ago and he is still small. Indeed when I was saddling him up next door to Generalissimo I wondered if we shouldn’t have been in the juvenile! But it was a courageous run and the Cape Flying has always been on the cards.”
Generalissimo started 13-10 favourite but could only manage fifth and was found to be lame on his left-fore.
Dean Kannemeyer refused to be carried away by Lars Kelp’s surprise winner and said: “I am going to progress slowly with him and do the right thing for the horse.”
Cold As Ice will turn out again in the Sceptre Stakes on 17 January after making virtually all under Cormack in the Laisserfaire Stakes to easily justify odds of 4-10 for Brian Finch and his partners.
Joey Ramsden, who is considering a tilt at the Klawervlei Majorca, said: “The Sceptre will keep her ticking over and save having to gallop her.”
Justin Snaith is determined not to ask Heartland to do too much too soon after Jackson’s full brother delighted Jack and Nancy Mitchell by readily landing the Racing. It’s A Rush Handicap in the hands of Richard Fourie.
Snaith said: “Winning by nearly ten lengths with Anton Marcus on debut shot me in the foot and I am going to take my time with him because he will be a good horse.
“He has had trouble with his shins and I have been using the same high frequency laser that I used on Legislate after the Durban July. It promotes growth and realigns the fibres in the bone.”
More turf success for Howells
PUBLISHED: December 29, 2014
David Thiselton
KZN champion trainer Duncan Howells rounded off a fine weekend when his Black Minnaloushe three-year-old Littleblacknumber made all in a fillies and mares Graduation Plate over 1200m at Greyville yesterday.
It was the third win of the weekend on the Greyville turf track for the Howells stable, following a double on Friday night, with Littleblacknumber repelling a number of challengers in the straight to win for the second time in succession.
Craig Eudey had mixed fortunes in the first race over 1600m as his 13/2 shot Mullins Bay filly Hunger Games won easily under Athandiwe Mgudlwa, while his outsider Hot Response dislodged the jockey early.
Keagan de Melo combined with Mark Dixon to win the second over 1400m with the favourite, The Poet, a hard-knocking colt by Brave Tin Soldier.
Sean Cormack won the third over 1000m comfortably aboard the speedy Dennis Drier-trained Var filly Black Velvet, while the odds-on shot Verge was caught in behind horses from an inside draw and could only run on for third.
The fourth over 1000m saw many tickets knocked out of the Pick 6 as the Chris Erasmus-trained Right Approach gelding Panza found extra under Billy Jacobson to repel the fancied Skrik For Niks.
The useful Paul Lafferty-trained Australian-bred Flying Spur filly Flying Loot jumped from the widest draw of all in the small six-horse field fifth race, a fillies and mares MR 88 handicap over 1000m, and she reeled in the speedy pacemaker Cherry Tripper to win comfortably under Stuart Randolph.
Lafferty later got a turf double when running one-two with the Stronghold gelding Double Clutch, who came from midfield under De Melo, and Auction King who fought out a MR 88 Handicap over 1900m.
The Gavin van Zyl-trained Trippi filly Se Agabor came from midfield under Derreck David to beat the favourite Cousin Annie in the seventh, a 1400m MR 76 fillies and mares handicap on the turf.
Both Van Zyl and Yeni completed a double in the last, a MR 88 handicap over 1900m on the turf, when the Classic Flag filly Qatar Springs kept the Howells filly Crime Victim at bay, although she did have to survive an objection.
Futura playing catch up
PUBLISHED: December 28, 2014
Michael Clower
Champions Cup winner Futura will be given a work-out at Kenilworth on Saturday in a bid to make up for being forced to miss his L’Ormarins Queen’s Plate preliminary.
Brett Crawford said: “He was coughing and had to be given medication to nip it in the bud, and the medication meant that he had to be scratched from the Diadem. That race was going to be a gallop so now I will bring him to the course to gallop him.”
Futura remains 7-2 second favourite for the J & B Met with Betting World which has eased Legislate from 2-1 to 22-10. The Vodacom Durban July winner will gallop at Kenilworth on Wednesday and continues to please Justin Snaith who said “he is doing well.”
Act Of War has drifted from 6-1 a week ago to 15-2, presumably because punters are waiting to see whether he will run or instead opt for either Saturday week’s L’Ormarins Queen’s Plate or the Investec Cape Derby on Met day.
Joey Ramsden, speaking from England, said on Saturday: “He came out of the Guineas very nicely and we will freshen him up this week.” Asked whether the colt could go for the Queen’s Plate, Ramsden said: “He could very well run but I will have a chat with Markus Jooste and a longer one with Derek Brugman.”
The handicappers raised Act Of War by 2kg to 117 for his Guineas win, the same merit rating as Legislate and half a kilo higher than Triple Crown winner Louis The King. However, when you take the sex allowance into account, Cape Fillies Guineas winner Majmu (114) is officially the best horse in the country.
Guineas runner-up Harry’s Son was left on an unchanged 114 while third-placed Kingvoldt was upped 3kg to 113. Ramsden said: “He is in a few places but he may well go for the R1 million CTS Book 1 Graduates race on 24 January.”
The Sean Tarry fourth and fifth, Imperial Gold and Zambezi River, were raised 7kg and 5.5kg to 102 and 101 but sixth-placed Arniston was left on 92 – much to his trainer’s relief! Snaith said: “He ran on well in the Guineas and he may now run in the Politician Stakes over 1 800m on Saturday week.”
Both Mljet (eighth) and Light The Lights (ninth) ran below form and will miss the Politician.
Vaughan Marshall said: “The draw is a killer, as we all know. Mljet will go to Jo’burg and run in the Betting World Gauteng Guineas (Feb 28). I am taking 26 horses to Joburg and they will leave in the middle of next month. My assistant Adele Alsop will go up there for the first month and then I will go.”
Glen Kotzen added: “Light The Lights did everything right but never kicked and he pulled up coughing. He goes straight for the Cape Derby.”
Picture: Futura at last season’s July gallops (Nkosi Hlophe)
Fourth Estate lands Christmas Handicap
PUBLISHED: December 28, 2014
David Thiselton
The Colin Scott-trained seven-year-old Dynasty gelding Fourth Estate showed his liking for the tight turf course at Greyville on Friday night when running on from off the pace under Alec Forbes to win the R200,000 Gr 3 Christmas Handicap over 1600m by a comfortable 2,25 lengths.
This was the first turf meeting at Greyville since November 9 and the course was presented in fine condition in front of another big Friday night crowd.
Fourth Estate has now won eight races, six of them on the Greyville turf, and earned bold black type for the first time. He was backed in from 14-1 to 10-1 and after jumping from pole position was settled on the rail in about midfield.
The second favourite Diamond King hit the front at the250m mark, but when Fourth Estate was switched inward he made up the ground quickly and kept going well to win easily. Isobar, the 9/2 favourite Candy Moon and Uncle Tommy had to be dropped out from wide draws and ran on from the back for third, fourth and fifth respectively.
Fourth Estate is owned by Colin Scott’s brother Rob together with B Bougardt and N Govender, was bred by Tertia Properties and has now earned R673,225 in stakes.
Picture: Fourth Estate (Nkosi Hlophe)