There are no plans – for the moment at any rate – to extend barrier trials to Cape Town and Johannesburg.

Phumelela boss Clyde Basel said: “It hasn’t been discussed yet but there is nothing on the table. We want to see what the upside is of the barrier trials in KZN.”

Racing there is run by Gold Circle which made the trials compulsory from March 1 for all newcomers and for any horse returning from a 150-day break. Phumelela runs racing in Cape Town and Johannesburg. A straw poll of trainers and punters at Kenilworth last Saturday revealed mixed views.

Picture supplied by Liesl King

Some of the older trainers said that the concept was tainted by the barrier trials staged in the 1990s when one unscrupulous trainer (long since dead) ran several horses in each one and manipulated them for the express purpose of hoodwinking the public and so getting a better price when his horses ran in an actual race.

Another said that in the summer the ground at Kenilworth is too firm to risk horses more than necessary but another was all for it and proposed staging them on alternate weeks at Kenilworth and Durbanville, the latter being filmed if the trials did not coincide with a racemeeting.

In the betting hall they still remember the villain of the 1990s – “He certainly didn’t help the punter. He was the biggest crook of the lot” – but they thought such trials would help with assessing two-year-olds.

Up in the Pocket Power lounge one racegoer, who seldom misses a meeting, ruled out any repeat of the old villainy, saying: “Things are more transparent these days, and anything that can be done to improve things for the punter would be welcomed.”

The trials would have obvious benefits with unraced horses – for punters, trainers and the animals themselves – particularly as the Cape Town training facilities are inferior to those at Summerveld. They would also be beneficial with horses returning after a break.

So often punters hear, or read, that a horse is “just having a gallop” and they are immediately placed in a quandary. The message is clear – the horse is not that busy. But such horses sometimes win, and often they are placed. They cannot be safely ignored. If the horse could be sidestepped into a barrier trial (where there is no betting), everybody would benefit.

By Michael Clower