Ordinary mid-week meetings on the Greyville poly are often just more of the same and one goes through the afternoon in a somnambulistic coma.
Then there are other days likes yesterday, that offer much to ponder. Do barrier trials work, is apprentice Lyle Hewitson as good as he is made out to be and does it pay to take notice of runners that take a drop in class?
Hot favourite Charge D‘Affaires put a kink in the form of Outlandos D‘Amour’s chances of winning the Gr1 Allan Robertson Championship at Scottsville on Saturday when she was beaten by Noemi in the card opener.
Charge D‘Affaires had no answer to the late challenge from Neomi, patiently ridden by Hewitson, who added another win to his fast-growing tally to squeak home aboard Karen and Greg Anthony’s Zadora in the seventh.
Garth Puller has been around the block more than once in a brilliant riding career. More than that, he was a horseman rather than a high-class ‘panel-beater’ and he has used the barrier trials to his advantage. Noemi was close-up in her trial without being asked for anything close to maximum and the experienced paid dividends yesterday.
Seasoned race watcher David Thiselton gives his expert opinions on the barrier trials on the Gold Circle website and anyone who took the trouble to look up his comments will have been rewarded.
“2nd 0,5 lengths Noemi (Godden/Puller 2yof 56kg) This athletic Crusade filly took a keen hold from the off and was under a tight hold when sitting behind the eventual winner. When switched out she displayed a nice daisy cutting action and was still under a tight hold at the line. She appears to have plenty of natural speed and some scope.”
There is a meeting of trainers and Gold Circle scheduled for today to discuss the merits of barrier trials and while they are an added frustration and expense to trainers, and there are some valid points that need to be addressed, barrier trials are far from misleading if viewed in the correct light. Australian heroine Winx had to trial before her last umpteenth Gr1 victory where she finished a distant fifth!
There is no doubting that Hewitson has what it takes and in a year where his senior opposition, notably Anthony Delpech, have been sidelined through injury, his quest for the National Jockey’s title has been made a lot easier and now a formality. But he is a class act which ever way you choose to look at it.
Under the current merit rating system of handicapping, one of the ploys by trainers is to run horses against superior opposition, get them tuned up without a penalty – a bonus being a drop in their rating – and then pitting them against horses of their own calibre. It doesn’t always pan out but it did for the Tony Rivalland-trained Fantasy Art who dropped a division and comfortably won the sixth.
By Andrew Harrison









